Cannonpointer » 22 Nov 2022, 11:46 pm » wrote: ↑ The funny thing is, all I'm doing is honestly assessing the territory - that is, stating that which is manifestly so, such that a fly on the wall could see and record it. I am reporting what measurably and verifiably has occurred in time and space. And this is precisely the world that Aristotle bequeathed us: a world of description rather than prescription.
Aristotle did not abolish magic - just magical thinking. Using his precepts and apprehending the world in the Joe Friday fashion (Just the facts, ma'am), we can observe the magic that IS, and describe the magic that IS. We no longer have to ascribe it to made up things - anthropomorphize it, sacrifice virgins to it, what have you. We no longer have to appease it. We can simply observe and report. We live in a world that we CAN accurately describe. Instead, we often prescribe the world we live in, which leads to ignoring reality and inventing phantasms like "over-population."
Just look what Jinn and GB - two very fine and well-meaning fellows - have done. They have taken a prescribed reality and quite literally poisoned their view of actual reality, based on a tautological prescription. They decided without considering the evidence what was so. Henry George was describing the world he saw, not the world he expected to see. I'm doing the same.
If I tell them they are superstitious, they will be insulted. But look at the world, look at their view of it, and TRY not to say ooga booga, population explosion! Ooga booga!
I'm not trying to be a dick. The person who convinced them that people are a problem was the dick. People are a resource. And the fossil layer is in the making. This planet is a giant living hopper that is making US a part of the fossil layer from which we sprang AS WE SPEAK. To suggest that we - creatures OF the fossil layer - can deplete the fossil layer is a snake eating its tail. We can play a part in its transformation - as a shovel-load of **** transforms your loam. But we cannot possibly deplete it as we are it.
Look at the energy we can take from ONE ATOM, and **** TELL ME we live in a world of finite resources.