This was a great OP. I totally agree with it, all enemies of Jews have become the enemies of the USA. And likely because Islam still forbids usury.
However, to play devils advocate, I have to say that Muslims bring some of the hate on themselves. I mean, FGM? Really? I am no feminist but womens rights in the Muslim world are nonexistent.
The refusal to allow depictions of Mohammed is weird as ****. The turbans and veils and hajis, the close minded and generally backward culture they have, the radical never ending holy wars (Iraq v Iran in the 80s for example) all make them less endearing..
The anti usury banking more than compensates. And hookahs are pretty cool. And belly dancing women. After all, I would rather we side with Islam against Judaism, than with Judaism against Islam.