User avatar
Cannonpointer
28 Aug 2022 11:10 am
User avatar
98% Macho Man
98% Macho Man
47,166 posts
RunningWithScissors » 28 Aug 2022, 10:59 am » wrote: ↑ I see how your logic works if the scales are tilted on the 1st weighing. 

What if the 1st weighing is even? Now you have 2 more chances, and only moving 2 marbles from side b to side a will not resolve it every time. You need to move 3 marbles.
Okay, so we agree that if the scales are ODD, my solution works?

Let us regress, then, to the issue of having only 4 suspects going into weighing #2, instead of 8. 

Place 2 suspects on side a and 1 on side b, with 1 control on side b.

3 possible outcomes:

1. Even. The sequestered marble is the suspect. Weigh it 1x1 against any of the 11 remaining controls to determine lighter or heavier. Solved.

2. Odd, side a heavier.  Weigh the two suspects on side a 1x1 against each other. If they are even, the one on side b is the odd man, and lighter. If odd, the heavier is the culprit. Solved.

3. Odd, side a is lighter. Weigh the two suspects on side a 1x1 a against each other. If they are even, the one on side b is the odd man, and heavier. If odd, the lighter is the culprit. Solved.

In neither scenario do I require the second weighing to use 4x4. I would argue my solution is the more elegant: less moving pieces. Image
 
When you complain, ur friends roll their eyes and ur enemies rejoice

"Because I SAY I am" is a todler's tantrum, not "science"

You cannot betray me - only yourself, to me.

Who cuts off your dick is not a friend

An opinion you won't defend is not your own

Humanity's Law of the Jungle: Survival NOT of the fittest, but of the tribe

When peeing in the pool, stand on the edge

If gender is not sex, why should a gender claim change what sex you shower with?
Updated less than a minute ago
© 2012-2026 Liberal Forum

Search