I am also inclined to believe the wurst about Isabel. But I also respect Ronjul's investigation-fu. He has never misinformed us.
I'm on the fence...
This is one to stay out of. When I saw the requests at .org and kfools response to give him access to see her PMs I said to myself this is one to stay out of.
BV is in question time out indefinitely, until he takes the pledge to answer questions one for one.