User avatar
Johnny You
31 Dec 2025 11:43 am
User avatar
Child Groomer, Sexual Predator
22,577 posts
Cannonpointer » 31 Dec 2025, 11:06 am » wrote: ↑ Oh, look. Another general accusation without specifics to defend. 

Ballsy. Right there with beevee for courage.
When do I get total immunity?  And links?

Whether Justices Alito and Thomas have made "unconstitutional" decisions is a matter of intense legal and political debate, with critics arguing their judicial philosophy, especially in overturning Roe v. Wade (Dobbs), undermines established constitutional rights, while supporters defend their originalist/textualist interpretations, viewing previous rulings as wrongly decided, such as in Obergefell (same-sex marriage). Specific actions, like Thomas's critique of affirmative action and Alito's questioning of Obergefell, draw accusations of bias, but they maintain these align with the Constitution's text, not outside influence, though ethical questions about gifts and undisclosed financial interests have led to calls for recusal and even impeachment. 
Key Areas of Controversy
  • no spam  (Overturning Roe v. Wade)
    • Alito: Wrote the majority opinion, arguing Roe was "egregiously wrong" because the Constitution doesn't mention abortion, thus it's not a protected right.
    • Thomas: Concurred, suggesting the Court should reconsider other precedents based on "substantive due process," like contraception and same-sex marriage.
    • Criticism: Critics argue overturning Roe ignores decades of precedent (stare decisis) and deprives women of a fundamental right, making the Dobbs decision itself unconstitutional in effect.
  • no spam  (Same-Sex Marriage)
    • Alito & Thomas: Have publicly criticized Obergefell, with Thomas suggesting the Court should revisit it, arguing it created rights not found in the Constitution and infringed on religious liberties.
    • Debate: Supporters of Obergefell see Alito and Thomas's stance as discriminatory and an attack on the 14th Amendment's equal protection, while Alito and Thomas see Obergefell as constitutionally flawed.
  • no spam
    • Thomas: Strongly opposes affirmative action, arguing for a "colorblind Constitution" that prohibits all racial discrimination, including policies meant to promote diversity, viewing them as unconstitutional. 
Ethical Concerns & Recusal
  • Allegations of undisclosed gifts and financial dealings by Thomas and Alito have led to public debate and calls for recusal from cases where their benefactors or spouses are involved, with some lawmakers introducing impeachment articles against Thomas, alleging they create a "constitutional crisis". 
In Summary
Alito and Thomas believe their decisions uphold the Constitution by adhering to original meaning and text, while critics argue their actions, particularly in Dobbs, disregard precedent and established rights, making them unconstitutional in practice, leading to ongoing legal and ethical battles. 
 
DUMP THE TRUMP SLUMP 2026!
Bump Caps Recommended..
Updated 3 minutes ago
© 2012-2026 Liberal Forum

Search