User avatar
Huey
16 Jan 2026 5:05 am
User avatar
      
37,337 posts
Blackvegetable » 15 Jan 2026, 5:37 pm » wrote: ↑ Neither point is crucial in determining whether this use of force was "objectively reasonable." Even if Good was simply trying to leave rather than trying to assault Ross, and regardless of whether the car made contact with him, it would have been reasonable for him to worry about his safety when the SUV began moving, since he had positioned himself (contrary to standard police training) in front of the vehicle. 

Ross quickly moved out of the way, the solution that the Justice Department recommends in situations like this. It's not clear whether he was still in the vehicle's path when he fired the first shot, which hit the lower left corner of the windshield. But he was clearly not in the SUV's path when he fired the second and third shots, which entered the car through the front window on the driver's side. When Tapper asked Noem about the justification for those shots, she noted that Ross was making a "split-second" decision, which might count in his favor even if that decision seems mistaken in retrospect.

That's assuming it made sense to think shooting Good was an effective way to neutralize the threat her car allegedly posed. The actual result was that the SUV careened down the street without guidance, stopping only after it crashed into a car parked on the left side. If anything, Ross aggravated any danger the car may have posed by killing the person who was steering it.

https://reason.com/2026/01/14/the-fbi-thinks-renee-goods-anti-ice-activism-is-relevant-in-deciding-whether-killing-her-was-justified/?utm_source=Reason+Magazine&utm_campaign=02dfa0edcc-reason_brand%7Cnew_at_reason%7C2026_01_15&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_31d7ef7f57-02dfa0edcc-587966116
I am glad you agree with the subject of thread,  the ICE agent was hit by the car.

Assh ole, WH by are you still spewing ****?
BV is in question time out indefinitely, until he takes the pledge to answer questions one for one.

The Pledge viewtopic.php?f=3&t=100927
Popular Vote Totals 2024 viewtopic.php?p=2685476#p2685476
BV's Sporter Losshttps: viewtopic.php?p=2610828#p2610828
BV 33 miles: viewtopic.php?p=2747521#p2747521
Sources viewtopic.php?p=2589152#p2589152
Updated less than a minute ago
© 2012-2026 Liberal Forum

Search