Cannonpointer » 18 Jul 2022, 10:24 am » wrote: ↑
Well, let's just make this a syllogism, which will require you to dispute one of the propositions or accept the logical conclusion. Syllogisms leave no room for cloudy communications.
1. Free enterprise is a function of humans being human and will always exist, even if the state outlaws it.
2. Capitalism is a function of the state, requiring trading boards, and cannot exist but by state patronage. If the state outlaws capitlism, it ceases to exist.
3. Free enterprise and capitalism are two different things by their nature.
Do you dispute either proposition?
well yeah. I disagree with proposition 2. I would associate capitalism with adam smith...who was basically just asking the government to step away from free enterprise. ENgland at the time was actually very socialist and had a corporatist economy run by guilds. Smith wanted that to go away. he wanted tariffs to go away.
the problem here is the fake distinction between public and private power. If the state steps away from economic control...then that simply creates a vacuum that will be filled by other people. Monied elites will obtain control of the economy, and they will inhibit free enterprise.
thus the new deal of FDR was basically an attempt to get the state to enforce regulations that make free enterprise possible via opposition to monopoly control.
but the new deal...while helpful...ultimately failed because it refused to address the problem of banks and wall street.